Viewpoint: Peace breaks out in robotic patents war?

Following a three-year-long authorized dispute over alleged patent infringement, Ocado and Norwegian robotic tech firm, AutoStore, have reached an out-of-court settlement. However the robotic patent struggle is way from being over.

Whereas the settlement between the 2 corporations is, largely, confidential, it has been made public that AutoStore can pay Ocado £200m in instalments, presumably to compensate the latter for the industrial use of sure patented applied sciences.

Robotic patents

It has additionally been revealed that each corporations will probably be sharing components of their respective patent portfolios with one another underneath licence – particularly those who pre-date 2020 – however they will additionally proceed to earn royalties by licensing them independently to 3rd events too. Crucially, Ocado has retained unique rights to its Single House Robotic, which is at the moment underneath licence to corporations within the US, France and Australia.

On this case, it actually appears that Ocado has come out on high, significantly as AutoStore initiated the dispute by bringing six patent infringement claims in 2020. Patent legal professionals performing for Ocado determined to countersue in 2021, and the remainder is historical past. Nevertheless, AutoStore hasn’t come off too badly. Whereas the result for AutoStore is expensive, the enterprise has successfully entered right into a duopoly with one in every of its rivals; having access to helpful applied sciences that would serve to strengthen its industrial place.

For Ocado, the out-of-court settlement will serve to underline the corporate’s growing dominance as a warehouse tech innovator, whereas ringfencing its ‘crown jewels’ – the patented applied sciences that underpin its Single House Robotic. The £200m money cost, which is payable over two years, is a big quantity – equating to about 10% of Ocado Group’s income in 2022. Moreover, the beneficial out-of-court settlement will serve to advertise the corporate’s increasing Ocado Options division.

If there's a key studying for potential litigators it needs to be that taking issues to court docket can generally backfire and an adversarial method received’t essentially ship the very best consequence. Within the case of patent disputes, courts have the ability to order an injunction to dam the sale of any infringing items, and require the infringer to pay compensation for misplaced income, however they will’t order the type of mutually acceptable industrial settlement that has been reached right here.

Cross-licencing

The cross-licencing settlement reached by Ocado and AutoStore is an instance of a artistic, cooperative association that provides industrial benefits to each events. Such agreements will not be unusual, however they not often come to mild because of the confidentiality surrounding them. As most skilled patent attorneys know, in the event you look deeply sufficient, there are sometimes alternatives to succeed in a decision that appears past a purely money settlement.

Typically, the agreements reached signify a significant industrial alternative for the companies concerned. For instance, companies working in numerous geographies might select to settle their variations by forging a worldwide distribution settlement and boosting their respective revenue-generating potential consequently. Various dispute decision is inspired by UK courts and companies ought to litigate solely as a final resort. If a court docket listening to proves inevitable, any prices payable are more likely to be diminished if the choose can see that real efforts have been made to resolve the matter out of court docket.

For robotics innovators, the danger of being infringed or dealing with an infringement declare is comparatively excessive. It is because the patent panorama on this discipline of analysis and growth continues to be evolving and attracting a gradual stream of latest entrants. Current gamers are competing for market share. Defending patented applied sciences is crucial to their enterprise mannequin, and due to this fact, enforcement is extra possible.

Inventive

Earlier than dashing to concern a stop and desist letter, robotic tech innovators who imagine their patent portfolio has been infringed ought to search recommendation from an IP skilled who will focus on a whole vary of choices.

Whereas the robotic patent struggle is way from being over, the settlement agreed by Ocado and AutoStore might encourage extra artistic, industrial resolutions sooner or later.

Alexander Ford is Senior Affiliate at European mental property agency Withers & Rogers.

View extra : IGBT modules | LCD displays | Electronic Components